Monday, June 24, 2013

Hate Poem (Love) vs What I Want (Hate)


The two poems that seem to resemble each other the most from 180 More Extraordinary Poems for Every Day are “What I Want” by George Bilgere and “Hate Poem” by Julie Sheehan. Both authors have strong emotions they feel about one person, that emotion being hate or so they want us to believe.


“What I Want” by George Bilgere is a lengthy poem. It has 29 stanzas but the author breaks it up into three lines per stanza making it easier to read. The undercurrent of the poem is spelled out in the epigraph “for my marriage 1996-2000.” The dates remind me of something that would be written on the headstone of someone’s gravesite.  It was either four short years or four long years. My curiosity was piqued and I had to know more. At first glance, “Hate Poem” by Julie Sheehan’s seems to be a poem about hate she feels for someone but I was not so sure after reading “I hate you truly. Truly I do" (Sheehan 1). What does this statement mean? Is she trying to convince the reader of her hate for this person? Does the narrator really hate him or is she being ironic? 





“What I Want” starts off nice enough “I want a good night’s sleep" (Bilgere 1) but soon turns ugly “I would like for my ex-wife to get leprosy” (14). The narrator talks about the sadness in his life, failed marriage, his father’s drinking and the loss of his mom. The narrator talks fondly about past relationships “And lie once more with Cecelia / In the summer of 1985 / On a blanket in the backyard of our house / In Denver and watch the clouds expand" (7-10), “And spend the entire afternoon in my dorm room / With Corrine Spellman, trying to remember / What we were talking about, wondering / Whether, in fact, we had had sex yet" (36-39) but the focus always turns back to his ex-wife and the many ways he would like to see her suffer. I loved the way George Bilgere found ways of expressing how he would like to hurt or embarrass his ex-wife “ And perhaps a stray bolt of lightning / Strikes my ex-wife as she steps from her car” (Bilgere 30-31) and then in another stanza say, “I want spark a bowl of Maui Wowie” (Bilgere 35) or “I want world peace" (19).


“Hate Poem” goes into great detail trying to make the reader and herself believe that she really hates this person. The fact that she goes into great detail shows how obsessed she is with this person. “Everything about me hates everything about you. / The flick of my wrist hates you. / The way I hold my pencil hates you” (Sheehan 2-4). Her detailed list of her hate for this person symbolizes her love for this person. She is always thinking about him and sees him in every aspect of her everyday activities. The strongest example of of love “My lungs, duplicitous twins, expand with the utter validity of my hate, which can never have enough of you / Breathlessly, like two idealists in a broken submarine" (23-24). In essence she is saying that with her every breath she is thinking about him and she cannot survive without him.  The first time I read this poem it was obvious to me that the narrator clearly loves this person very much.


Whether it is the hate of the ex-wife in “What I Want” by George Bilgere or the play on words in “Hate Poem" by Julie Sheehan, it is clearly obvious to the reader that the narrators still have powerful feelings for the people they are talking about. 

2 comments:

  1. I disagree, I believe in the poem "What I Want" he truly hates his ex-wife. Their marriage was probably unbarable and that is why he writes the epigraph. It is like his marriage is dead and he wants to bury it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree he does hate is ex-wife in 'What I Want' it's 'Hate Poem' that is really about love.

      Delete