Relationships within a family are often complicated and difficult
during the best of circumstances. As we look at David Small’s graphic novel Stitches: A Memoir, we see that he
shares two totally different relationships between his mother and his father. He
saw his father as the heroic doctor with the “…Miraculous wonder rays that
could cure anything” (Small 27) and his mother as the disciplinarian, “You know
the rules” (29).
The only interactions ever witnessed between David and his dad is under
the guise of a doctor/patient relationship. When David would get sick, Dad
would step in, not in a comforting fatherly way, but in the capacity of a doctor/patient
relationship. When David had sinus or digestive tract problems, Dad…”knew what
to do” (20), he would prescribe medication, give him shots and enemas. His cure
for David’s sinus problems was to give him multiple x-rays. Dad was acting in
the capacity of doctor, doing what he thought was best for this patient. When
David was fifteen, his Dad admitted to him, “I gave you cancer” (287). No one
knew back then that giving a child that many x-rays at “…Two-to-four-hundred
rads,” could cause cancer (285).
When we think of moms, we think of someone who is compassionate and
caring towards their children, someone who will comfort you when you are sick
or hurt. This is definitely not the case when it came to his relationship with
his mother. His mother never let him cuddle when he was sick; she never showed
him any kind of love or compassion. She is depicted as someone who is there to
give the medicine dad prescribes and is seen tossing David’s teddy bear into
the bed with him when he is sick. When dad is giving David a shot, Mom is shown
with both hands on his chest holding him down.
David goes on separate spring break vacation with mom to grandma’s
house. Mama gives him a little family history during the trip there. He learns
that his grandparents had to get married because grandma was pregnant with his
mama. Grandpa’s parents did not like grandma and treated her poorly. When his mama, Betty was born, her doctor
“discovered her heart….was over on the wrong side of her chest” (69). He learns
that grandpa died when mama was ten and grandpa’s parents kicked grandma and
mama off of the family property. David soon gets a glimpse of the kind of abuse
his mother had to endure as a child. Grandma has fixed his supper and he really
doesn’t like it so she tells him, “Then don’t eat it. Git upstairs and get
ready for bed.” David complains about it still being light outside, but that
sets grandma off. “I said Git. No Back-talk!” then drags him upstairs (90).
Before putting him to bed she washes his hands under scalding hot water. Later
that evening, David is expressing his fear of grandma and says, “…she’s…Craze-…Y!”
(101), mom doesn’t come to his defense. She covers his mouth and just as a
child would do, she turns to the door to see if her mom is listening. She then
turns to David and grabs him by the shoulders, shakes him and says, “LISTEN TO
ME: I don’t’ ever want to hear you use that word again...NEVER! (102).
David never received any kind of
emotional support from his father therefore; he had no emotional attachment to
his dad. His dad was the person responsible for his cancer as
well as the one to get him the care need for his treatment. David quotes a line
from a poem by Edward Dahlberg to describe his mom, “Nobody heard her tears;
the heart is a fountain of weeping water which makes no noise in the world”
(327). In the end, when his mother sheds that final tear and he touches her
face, I get a sense that all the abuse he endured as a child has been
forgiven.


I agree with you, in the type of role that the dad took. I wonder if all the fathers that are doctors are the same way. I have a cousin that is a doctor, yet he is not a father. However, I remember clearly how he reacted after he saw the fallowing day after I had just given birth to my son. After he hugged me he said to me, “your to pale where’s your doctor, I need to speak to him I need to know if you lost too much blood,” which I did. But I guess is that instinct of a doctor that they have in themselves. However, I liked the way you evaluated their relationships.
ReplyDelete